The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency yesterday released its annual report on greenhouse gas emissions from the nation’s largest sources of pollution, revealing that we still have enormous progress to make in cutting carbon.
The big bombshell was that in 2013, greenhouse gas emissions actually increased. That’s right, increased. Not only that, but the increase was tied to increased coal burning.
It’s a shameful reminder of how the fossil fuel industry continues to dig our nation deeper into climate debt. With the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) calling for a 40-70% reduction in carbon emissions below 2010 levels by mid-century, the last thing we need is an increase in emissions. It underscores that the fossil fuel industry’s resistance to limiting its pollution needs to be countered more fiercely than ever if we have any hope of making progress.
This is especially the case with regards to methane. Sure, the EPA yesterday hyped its claim that methane emissions from fracking have decreased 73% since 2011. But as Bobby Magill at Climate Central noted, the agency’s report fails to fully account for methane leaks at oil and gas wells, which studies have found can approach 12% in some regions.
What’s more, EPA’s data relies on a faulty assumption that methane has a global warming potential of 25. The global warming potential is a measure of how potent a greenhouse gas is compared to carbon. Yet as we reported before, the latest findings from the IPCC indicate that over a 20-year timeframe, methane actually has a global warming potential of 86.
In other words, the world’s leading body of climate scientists say that one ton of methane equals 86 tons of carbon dioxide.
For EPA’s report, it means that estimates of carbon dioxide equivalency associated with methane are more than half a billion metric tons too low, an error of 70%. The EPA may be correct that there was a reduction in methane since 2011, but with such grossly inaccurate emissions reported, it seems like the hole we’re trying to dig out of is just getting deeper (this is confirmed by the latest studies finding that more fracking for gas not only won’t reduce carbon emissions, but will also undermine renewable energy).
Another bombshell is that underground coal mine methane emissions increased by nearly 25% between 2012 and 2013. The industry reported methane emissions equal to 41 million metric tons of carbon in 2013 (of course, with a global warming potential of 86, it would actually be more than 141 million metric tons).
No matter how you slice it, though, the data shows that coal mines are responsible for nearly 20% of all methane emissions in the U.S., a staggering figure.
In case you’re wondering, where these gassy coal mines are located, the majority are in Appalachia, but a few mines in the West–namely the San Juan mine in northwestern New Mexico, the Westridge mine in Utah, and Arch Coal’s West Elk mine in Colorado–made the top 20. The top emitter, the Walter Energy mine in Alabama, reportedly released nearly 5 million tons of carbon dioxide equivalent. That’s more than an average coal-fired power plant. Here’s the full list of gassy mines >>
More than anything, the latest greenhouse gas reporting data confirms that we can’t afford to delay carbon reductions. It’s why last week, WildEarth Guardians joined a coalition of organizations in calling on the Obama Administration to stay firm in its commitment to curtail methane from oil and gas operations, and it’s why we’re digging in more aggressively than ever on our challenges to more coal mining and burning, and more fracking, in the American West.
We have major challenges ahead, but also major opportunities. It’s time to step it up.